Posted by: Russ Howell
Corporate Solutions
Strategy and Portfolio Planning’s (SPP) Optimizing Capital Task Force, which I lead with Richard Podos, sponsored a well-attended panel discussion to explore the one constant amidst today’s ever-changing social dynamics: money talks. But what is the language of money? Do we share a common grammar across the corporate real estate community?
In the panel’s collective experience, there is very little consistency in the approach to decision-making when it comes to investing capital in corporate portfolios. Our discussion started with a recounting of a few real-life “horror stories.” For example, the Fortune 500 CFO who compared purchasing a new building to buying his house and asserted that his cost of capital was the CD rate (and whose company no longer exists). These tales were proceeded by exploring a few of the many analytical frameworks, discount rates, and theories of capital efficiency in use today that lead to very different conclusions and often with large financial consequences.
The panel also summarized the results of a recent Task-Force sponsored survey about current trends and practices, which lent additional support to the basic thesis that a consistent doctrine or framework is not part of current practice. There appears to be no real reason why this must be so, because as a very general statement, the underlying financial principles should be valid across industries.
In my mind, the panel’s discussion served mainly as a public recognition that a problem exists, and as a starting point toward its definition. The solution remains to be found; but on a hopeful note, the session ended with a challenge from the audience to the panel: if the problem exists and is of real magnitude, and if a consistent doctrine can be defined, the panel and Task Force should commit themselves to developing and promulgating such a doctrine. We were happy to accept—stay tuned.
If you’re interested in this topic and would like to follow or participate in our progress, please join our conference calls, held at 2:00 p.m. EDT on the first Tuesday of every month. You can dial in on 866 259 9955, participant code 639 280 0987.